if you had read my post correctly I didn't even mention his knock on there were plenty others dropping the ball too ie lynch, I was commenting on how in the last two games he's gone for the Hollywood play interception when up against two attackers instead of just tackling the ball carrier that's all you can ask on a two on one ,the ball carrier might stuff his pass up or choose to go alone in which case you tackle him

He'll be on more then Eden though, we agree on that.

Unless Eden's paid by the error

Sharons error on Monday cost you 2 points. Shall we compare tries scored?

If only Eden caught the derby bomb...

Hardly the only (or indeed main) KPI for a full back.

1 point actually, same as Eden's error at manchester

Rubbish argument. More than just tries. He's cost you numerous tries.

Over last 3 games I'd have Eden over Shannon easy.

The entirety of the rest of the season Shannon easy!!!

McDonnell seems to have gone off the boil in the last 3 or 4 games. Unsure if this is a symptom or a cause of our problem

error? you cant point to that.

Well it comes down to the whole season, particurley the last games when it counts.

OK, I guess you could say he bottled it but still an error IMO. Still probably cost you a point but I think we'd have scored anyway as you're side were mentally beaten