Quote Shaggoth="Shaggoth"Seconded. Great support player in superleague but sets up nothing. He's not a halfback in that sense. He looked pretty poor yesterday.'"
Not that old chestnut again. This isn't 2004. McGuire does set things up - just look at his try assists this season (15 IIRC). Unfortunately he's still not the complete stand-off - maybe if he'd gone to the NRL early in his career some of these deficiencies could have been sorted out.
I agree he had a very poor game though, and it wouldn't be unfair to drop him for next week. That said he was one of the few players to cause NZ serious problems in the WC last year, so it's not like he's incapable of putting in the good performances at this level.
On the defence issue, any of the England backs would have looked poor having to defend an overlap against the likes of Inglis and Slater. This has to be a failing of the sliding defence in operation rather than the fault of any individual player. If you want someone to blame it should be the coach.
Also, FWIW, although Burgess looked good when he ripped in in the second half his ball security needs some work for him to be better at this level.